Comparison

BeeKeeper vs. a spreadsheet

The spreadsheet works right up until the person who built it leaves.
The short version
A spreadsheet is not a mistake. It is free, it opens on any machine, and every person on your board can read one. It is designed for a person who knows what they put in each cell — which is exactly what makes it hard the year somebody else takes over.

What follows is what changes when a group grows past one account and thirty transactions a year: a second account, a hundred transactions, four people who need the numbers between meetings, and an audit committee in June.

Side by side

24 things a school group actually needs
Capability
BeeKeeper
Spreadsheet
Costs nothing
The honest first row. A spreadsheet is free and we are not.
No
Yes
Opens anywhere, no account needed
No
Yes
Works with no internet
No
Yes
You can put anything in any cell
Flexibility is why spreadsheets win, and why they drift. A ledger has rules on purpose.
No
Yes
Debits and credits that have to balance
Yes
You can build it. Nothing enforces it.
A permanent record of who changed what
Yes
File version history, which is not the same thing
Two-signature approval on the record
Yes
An email thread, if it was kept
Receipt attached to the transaction
Yes
A link to a folder, if someone keeps it current
Bank transactions arrive on their own
Yes
Download a file and paste it in
Reconciliation with a difference that must reach zero
Yes
A column of checkmarks
A closed month that cannot quietly change
Yes
Nothing stops an edit to last March
Roles — who can see, who can edit, who only approves
Yes
Sharing is per file
Budget vs. actual without keeping a second sheet
Yes
A second sheet, updated by hand
Chart of accounts mapped to IRS Form 990
Yes
Regrouped by hand each January
PTA-format annual financial report
Yes
A template you fill in
Check printing and a check register
Yes
The checkbook stays
Imports your existing spreadsheet
Transactions, budget and vendors each import from CSV or Excel.
Yes
It is already a spreadsheet
Treasurer's report for the board meeting
The one-page summary a board votes to accept.
Yes
No
Receipts read by AI, not retyped
Yes
No
Imported bank transactions coded by AI, with a confidence score
Yes
No
A bank row that duplicates an entry you already made, caught before it posts
Yes
No
Volunteer expense submissions read and checked against what they typed
Yes
No
Connect your own AI assistant to your books, read-only
BeeKeeper runs an MCP server, so you can ask Claude or ChatGPT about your ledger.
Yes
No
Price
$299.40/year, unlimited people
Free, or whatever your office suite costs
Built inNot available
$299.40
Per year, everything included
30 days
Free trial, no credit card
$0
For councils and districts
Unlimited
People on your books, at no extra cost

Four things a spreadsheet cannot have, however well it is built

None of these are about skill. They are about what a grid of cells is.
No record of who changed what

Version history tells you a cell changed. It does not tell you the board approved $1,200 for field trips, or that the number was edited three weeks after they did.

Nothing has to balance

A double-entry ledger notices a transaction entered on one side and not the other. A spreadsheet will happily total a column that is missing a row and show you a confident, wrong number.

Reconciliation is a feeling

Ticking off the statement works right up until the difference is $43.17 and you are hunting for it at 11pm with no list of what is still outstanding.

It belongs to whoever built it

The formulas are in one person's head and the file is in one person's Drive. The next treasurer inherits a workbook she is afraid to touch, and touches it anyway.

PTA accounting that runs itself

Built for school groups. Free for 30 days, no credit card required.

Start free trial
Don't wait for July
The instinct is to switch at the start of a fiscal year, because that is when the books are clean. You do not need to. We import your chart of accounts, your budget, your vendors and your history, and we handle the awkward parts — opening balances, checks written but not yet cleared, months you have already reconciled. Mid-year is a normal week for us.

The best time to plant a tree was twenty years ago. The second best time is today.

Your spreadsheet is not wasted

Most moves take about thirty minutes. Send us the sheet as it is — we would rather see the real one than a tidied copy — and our support team will map it with you. You do not have to get it into a particular shape first, and you are not doing it alone.
  1. 1
    Tidy three columns

    Date, amount, description. That is the minimum we need. Keep your category column if you have one and it becomes your chart of accounts.

  2. 2
    Import it as CSV or Excel

    Transactions, your budget, and your vendor list each import from a spreadsheet. The work you have already done comes with you.

  3. 3
    Set balances and reconcile once

    Enter each account's balance as of the day you start, then reconcile that first month against the statement. When the difference hits zero, the sheet becomes history instead of homework.

Keep your books where school groups keep theirs

Accounting built for PTAs, PTOs, booster clubs and ASBs. Free for 30 days, no credit card, cancel anytime.